modern jewish thought

CASRN329/629 fall 2005

 

Course description Like its medieval predecessor, the Judeo-Arab philosophy of Al Andalus, modern Jewish philosophy of religion is a hybrid formed from an indigenous religious tradition and a universalizing concept of rationality. In contrast to their medieval predecessors, however, the modern thinkers are also apologists, responding to the theological-political critique of religion of the 17th century that became the foundation of the modern state as the framework of the liberty and happiness of individuals. The thinkers we will study actively and creatively participated in the discourse of modernity while defending the meaning of the Jewish religious tradition, its sacred Scriptures, and belief in God.

Required textbooks

Baruch Spinoza, A Theologico-Political Treatise. (Transl. Shirley) Hackett Publ.

Roger Scruton, Spinoza. A very short introduction (OUP)

Moses Mendelssohn, Jerusalem or on Religious Power and Judaism. U Press of New England: 1984

Hermann Cohen, Religion of Reason Our of the Sources of Judaism

Michael Zank, The idea of atonement in the philosophy of Hermann Cohen

Franz Rosenzweig, Philosophical and Theological Writings (Hackett, 2000)

Recommended background reading

Amos Elon, The Pity of it all

 

Assessment and grading

Attendance, participation, brief homework assignments, and two discussion protocols: 40%

Two papers (30% each).

 

Reading schedule (temporary; more details forthcoming)

PART I: ENLIGHTENMENT CRITIQUE OF REVELATION AND THE FREEDOM OF THOUGHT

Week One

Sept 7/9

Spinoza, TPT

Roger Scruton, Spinoza. A very short introduction

 

Week Two

Sept 12/14/16

Spinoza, TPT

 

Week Three

Sept 19/21/23

Spinoza, TPT

 

Week Four

Sept 26/28/30

Spinoza, TPT

Leo Strauss, How to Study Spinoza's Theologico-Political Treatise (pdf)

(Footnotes to Strauss, "How to Study"; pdf)

 

Week Five

Oct 3/5/7

Mendelssohn, Jerusalem Introduction and Pt I

 

Week Six

Oct 12/14

Mendelssohn, Jerusalem Pt I

 

Week Seven

Oct 17/19/21 

Mendelssohn, Jerusalem Pt II

 

PART II: HISTORY, TRADITION, AND REDEMPTION

Week Eight

Oct 24/26/28

Jewish Philosophy Reader:

History and Tradition in 19th-Century Jewish Thought

Ch. 20 Scholarship and Religious Reform (pdf)

Ch. 21 The Authority of Tradition (same pdf file as Ch. 20; scroll down to Ch 21)

Ch. 22 Revelation, Redemption, and the Nature of Judaism (pdf)

 

Week Nine

Oct 31/Nov 2/4

Zank, The idea of atonement in the philosophy of Hermann Cohen

 

Week Ten

Nov 7/9

Cohen, Religion of Reason

 

Week Eleven

Nov 14/16/18

Cohen, Religion of Reason

 

Week Twelve

Nov 21

Cohen, Religion of Reason

 

Week Thirteen

Nov 28/30/Dec 2

Rosenzweig, Phil and Theol Writings

 

Week Fourteen

Dec 5/7/9

Rosenzweig, Phil and Theol Writings

 

Week Fifteen

Dec 12

Rosenzweig, Phil and Theol Writings