Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 6 comments on Tale of Fantasies Fulfilled Takes Redstone Prize

  1. Having frequented the Redstone Festival a number of times, I’ve become increasingly disappointed with first place recognition given to reactionary films that hold no substance. In the first five minutes of Sombra Azul, audience members may have questioned whether BU was teaching a course in how to make cheesy porn, as demonstrated by the laughter accompanying the opening erotic scenes. The reactionary events like rape and unrealistic vulgar behavior was a quick and cheap way to elicit audience emotion but the whole of the film lacks motive and good story. While it does follow a linear narrative, the film must be labeled “experimental” due to the unabashed, undeveloped plot. Kudos to the director of film for making a weak story visually appealing. Sombra Azul is too reminiscent of the well produced but poorly written Fratelli Brothers film from last year and seemingly communicates to students that in order to win you don’t need a comprehensive good film…high quality production, in spite of a sub-par storyline, is good enough! The Boston University Film Department should be concerned that its integrity may be jeapordized by continuing to award flawed films honors.

  2. *disclaimer: This was my first Redstone Festival

    I agree with the previous comment: A bit too much fluff over substance. The issue at hand with the winning film is obviously an extremely serious subject (rape) that shouldn’t be taken lightly, but – with that being said – there were other films that had a developed plot and had just as much uniqueness in visual appeal as the winning film.

    My personal pick would have been “Mind the Gap”, a film that explored another intensely serious subject (suicide), but still assembled a well thought out plot with substantial character development (for a short film). And it really felt like a short “film” – and not just … I don’t want to degrade the winning film too much, but “Mind the Gap” didn’t feel like cinematographic art, which is how I felt the “Sombra Azul” was characterized in my eyes.

    Why “Mind the Gap” didn’t even finish in the top three is beyond me.

    But, I will say, aside from whether the winning film is controversial or not, the judges certainly had quite array of films to choose. I’m just not sure how one decides , for instance, between a 30-minute documentary on women’s basketball in Iowa and a 7 comedy minute piece on werewolves.

  3. I have to say, I am in complete agreement with the posts before me. I really enjoyed Sombra Azul for its bold creativity and unique presentation, but I don’t think it presented a coherent enough idea, even for a short experimental film.

    In one of the quotes above, Muvdi says that the subject of the film is the idea that our sexual fantasies should never come true because they do not live up to our expectations – but I don’t see exactly how this idea relates the film I saw. The woman was not, as I understood it, fantasizing about being raped by the swimmer but rather about having sex with him in the pool. The rape scene that followed was disturbing, but, as the post below comments, rather unwarranted – it seemed to be an attempt to invoke a strong reaction from the audience and to jolt us out of the previous dream-like scenes. However, the scene did not seem to have a logical connection to the previous scenes (except for the sex) and therefore produced no effect on me, except for horror and disgust. I was also confused about how the woman ended up in the pool at the end of the film – I assumed that she died, but this doesn’t seem logical because the man left after raping her.

    I also really enjoyed Mind the Gap and think it deserved a place in the top three, over both Sombra Azul and Werewolf Trouble. In fact, I enjoyed all three films that did not win awards a great deal more than the films that did. I do not claim to be an expert on the subject, and it is quite possible that I missed some of the astounding aspects of the winning films; but these are the two cents of a viewer.

  4. I disagree with the previous posts. Sombra Azul clearly surpassed the other films in nearly every aspect of the production (and post production) process. Every shot was breathtaking, and I thought the story had more substance than any other film at the festival.

    As for “Mind the Gap” its cliche mise-en-scene and nauseatingly typical character focus seemed laughable, at least in terms of originality. The director wanted the film to be “Juno” or “Little Miss Sunshine” so badly, I began to grow bored. It was well done, but met every “indie movie” stereotype in the book.

  5. * I found it interesting that the award winning films weren’t actually films at all, they all appear to have been shot on video. To say that the production value for Sombra Azul surpassed all others is naive. Anyone that has shot on film knows the ease of the “production” from video. Most people can “produce” something visually appealing on video, as evidenced by quality videos on youtube. Filmed productions require much more training and craft. Like seeing a painting on canvas vs. a jpg, actual film productions require much more craft and skill.
    * Production aside, the stories are what really carry a movie, which as mentioned below is a glaring flaw in Sombra Azul (sorry). Watching Auscultare it does seem as if the director tries to evoke sentiment from the audience by picking high profile subjects like rape and abortion. Speaking of “originality”, the “be careful for what you wish for” theme is so unoriginal and tired it is only reserved for midseason children’s TV shows. The true winners were Mind the Gap, A Simple Taste and Werewolf Troubles.
    * Last years nominations can be found at http://www.youtube.com/user/BUFILMTV. This years should appear on there so readers can pick for themselves.

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *