• Rich Barlow

    Senior Writer

    Photo: Headshot of Rich Barlow, an older white man with dark grey hair and wearing a grey shirt and grey-blue blazer, smiles and poses in front of a dark grey backdrop.

    Rich Barlow is a senior writer at BU Today and Bostonia magazine. Perhaps the only native of Trenton, N.J., who will volunteer his birthplace without police interrogation, he graduated from Dartmouth College, spent 20 years as a small-town newspaper reporter, and is a former Boston Globe religion columnist, book reviewer, and occasional op-ed contributor. Profile

Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 17 comments on Barnes & Noble at BU to Rent Textbooks

  1. So buying a used book and selling it back at the end of the semester essentially costs the same as renting.

    I guess giving up less money up front is a form of savings…

  2. I don’t think the publishers are going to be too happy about rentals. They might start doing what the movie industry has been doing for years, that is, to differentiate the licensing for individual use and licensing for rental use where the latter would be more expensive in licensing fee. After the dust settles, I don’t think the rentals will end up being much cheaper than used.

    Also, textbooks of many upper level classes are very valuable even after college, useful as reference books. It might be the only souvenir you end up walking away with you after graduation, besides your diploma, that you received good education. Promoting the use of textbook rentals could end up hurting our graduates.

    Introductory level classes, on the other hand, should probably not use textbooks especially if the textbook is more than $25. These classes develop skill and knowledge that are prerequisites for higher level courses, so you should be able to walk away with that stuff in your head. The instructor would prepare a couple of pages of required reading for each week of class, and keep a few copies of the textbook in the library in case if the student needs more examples or an alternative explanation of the problem.

    Oh yes, and there is always the library with textbook reserves, which the school provides for free. Why bother with Barnes and Noble?

  3. The campus book store is a complete rip off, and this rental program is just attempting to mask that fact. Even the examples given to persuade you of how great the rental program is are a joke. For one, lets take the PS 101 book example…That book is available from an online, market price based store used for $93 ($17 cheaper than the used price at Barnes and Nobel). This book is a newer edition (Jan. 2010), so assuming that no newer book comes out before this coming January, a student could expect to sell this book via the same website it was purchased from for at least $75, at the end of the semester. Even taking into consideration shipping ($4), this would leave the student at a net loss of $22. Now, I don’t know about you, but I’ll take that loss of $22 over the $66 Barnes & Nobels is charging for a rental any day.

  4. This is going to be a nightmare — there are no real savings, of course, as everyone can see, but it will take so much more time and effort trying to keep track of the inventory that is rented in an already more-complicated-than-it-looks business. So I guess the move is to satisfy the customer for about two weeks before picking up the textbooks (“Look at how much cheaper it is!”), until he/she realizes that this is basically the same as buying a used textbook (albeit with certainty that it’ll be taken back, but that’s a small gain).

    Further, the risks to which the bookstore is now exposed is a lot greater than usual now. What happens if a student doesn’t return the book? Certainly, he or she will be charged for the price of the book (or something similar), but as has happened in other colleges, cancelling the credit card is an easy solution. After all, it takes more of an effort (time- and money-wise) to track down the student offender than it would just to let him/her get away with it (that is, of course, if there are many thefts, which is unlikely).

    Lastly, according to the article:

    “The law also requires schools to give students ample time to shop for the best textbook deals by disclosing at registration the textbooks required for each class.”

    I was hoping that this was only for public institutions because this law is absolutely ridiculous from the professor’s standpoint. What happened to improving this or that, selecting a new book or taking off the syllabus another book, between semesters? This law makes nearly impossible those subtle changes any good professor is able to make in order to enhance his or her curriculum, based upon his or her experience the previous semester. I’m all for knowing the course material up-front, but this is a bit dramatic. I hope what I feel will happen doesn’t; however, it certainly seems likely that the tide will turn this way in many cases.

  5. I don’t think I could ever trust BU Barnes & Noble because I once bought a NEW book on Amazon that was cheaper than the price of USED book from BU B&N. Same edition and everything. Seriously. They have a reputation for being a rip off and this doesn’t change anything. If I’m going to do a rental, I will just go to Chegg.com instead.

  6. What type of person would pay 50% to rent a book? Thanks to the Internet, one can at least buy an "International Edition" book now for a fraction of the normal price, which apparently may still be less than renting a book! The quality is not as good, but the content is usually identical to that of a domestic book. That’s the way I buy my engineering books now.

  7. Buying a used book and intending to sell it back is risky, because even if a book will continue to be used, you can’t sell it back if the class is only offered every other semester. (The bookstore may assume the class will run again next year, but they won’t buy back your books without that guarantee.)

    Renting may not be cheaper ultimately, but it takes away that risk and instills an element of fairness in pricing. I think this is a step in the right direction.

  8. True, this is a new option. Not a very practical one, though, considering the alternatives:
    – I could rent my textbooks and save 55%. Cost of ownership: 45% of original price.
    – I could buy my textbooks at full price, and sell them second hand for slightly more than half price (the bookstore resells at 70% of original cost, and the demand seems very strong because they’re always out of stock on secondhand books). Cost of ownership: ~40% of original, assuming a modest resell price.
    – I could buy my textbooks second hand (paying 70% of original at BN, usually less when purchasing elsewhere), and then resell them for ~40% of original price. Cost of ownership: ~30% of original.

    Not to mention that by reselling your textbooks, you’re helping other college students by making their textbooks costs more affordable.

  9. The idea of renting tickles me. It’s basically just a guaranteed buyback (which stores have been doing for years) but they front load it, and charge you more if you never return it. Pretty clever. I use http://www.rent-a-textbook.com for my book rentals, it saved me a few bucks last semester.

  10. One word: Don’t let Barnes & Noble rip you off. They have been doing that for decades.

    Go buy textbook in other cheap places (plenty of them if you google it)

    Let them go bankrupt and they will. They deserve it.

  11. When I was an undergraduate at a SUNY school about ten years ago, there was an off-campus bookstore (unaffiliated with the college) that would ALWAYS sell books cheaper than the school bookstore. It would get interesting to see all of the gimmicks the school bookstore would come up with to lure students back into the campus store. Pretty much the only advantage the school bookstore offered was convenience. I personally liked having an excuse to get off campus for a while, even if it meant standing in line at Mando Books (any Cortland people out there remember that place?). So this really isn’t a new phenomenon. Campus auxiliary services aren’t about helping students, they’re about making a profit, any way you cut it.

  12. One of the books for GRS MA 711 is sold on Amazon for $98.44. Bookstore wants $192 (195% of what Amazon charges) for it, with no used copies available. The disclaimer on the bookstore’s website says that they carefully monitor prices. Some monitoring this is!
    Most books in this bookstore (judging from a personal experience) are sold for at least 20% more than the list price on websites like Amazon and BN.
    And while this is slightly off topic, why is the $9 steel water bottle and $40 decent quality sweat-shirt becomes $16 steel water bottle and $99 sweatshirt respectively when the BU logo is glued to it?
    Renting books seems as nonsense to me. If I purchase a book I expect to be able to use it when I want and how I want it. Most of the rentals have a 20 page printing restriction built in.
    The point is BN bookstore at Kenmore should stop gauging students instead of figuring out new and exciting ways of masquerading the exorbitant prices!

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *