• Jillian McKoy

    Senior Writer/Editor SPH School News, Office of Communications and Marketing

    Jillian McKoy is a senior writer and editor in the SPH Office of Communications and Marketing; she can be reached at jpmckoy@bu.edu. Profile

Comments & Discussion

Boston University moderates comments to facilitate an informed, substantive, civil conversation. Abusive, profane, self-promotional, misleading, incoherent or off-topic comments will be rejected. Moderators are staffed during regular business hours (EST) and can only accept comments written in English. Statistics or facts must include a citation or a link to the citation.

There are 2 comments on Airplane Noise May Be Bad for Your Health

  1. Maybe you should’ve also considered the military who are exposed to flight-line and flight-deck air craft noise. As for those in the flight path I’m a little skeptical that standing around while planes fly overhead is going to make them fat.

  2. The study problems begin in section 2.3. Data was selected based on nurses who lived in proximity to one of 90 airports. The FAA provided noise data every 5 years, whereas the nurses were surveyed every 2 years. So the researchers had to estimate addresses for data matching for a majority of the data points analyzed. Data points living 22.1 miles away from any airport were excluded.

    After a quick read of the study, I don’t see whether the researchers considered the impacts of a healthy diet & regular exercise? If a person decides to skip their workout, or eat a chimichanga and an apple fritter everyday, that can’t be blamed on aircraft noise. Did they consider that some nurses may work very long or stressful shifts, which may contribute to lack of exercise & healthy food? That can’t be blamed on aircraft noise. The researchers did exclude data when the participants reported cancer or diabetes or pregnancy (non-normal BMI). Also on first glance, the study looked at nurses home addresses, not addresses where they worked. 45% of the datapoints lived in the Norteast.

    I don’t see a comparison with a control group that lives in a noisy place not near an airport. I.e. I find it difficult to sleep in San Francisco with the noise of the city traffic, construction, beep-beep backup signals, car alarms, sirens, cable cars, fog horns, etc. I can’t hear airplanes in San Francisco most of the time. The city noise drowns out the airplane noise (except on Blue Angel demonstration flight days).

Post a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *